Quite good! Stirring stuff and, giving
it some thought later, don't there were any glaring anachronisms,
none that really stuck out for me anyway (That is, items and
attitudes that could not have existed at the time the movie takes
place). Naturally, the princess is a bit more rebellious than one
would expect and Jack (The
Giant Slayer) is treated quite well by his social betters,
but all in all, it seems pretty true to the period.
As I was getting some coffee for the
movie (the local theaters carried coffee for a bit, so they've told
me I can carry a cup of coffee in), the salesperson at the
convenience store commented on movies plundering material from the
past. Yeah, Jack is an adaptation of the old Jack and the
Beanstalk tale, but yes, plundering the past for story material
is hardly new.
The
Golem was a 1921 movie that was based on old Jewish legends.
When I saw it, it immediately brought to mind The Hulk
from Marvel Comics. Thor,
of course also from Marvel Comics, derives directly from Norse
legends. The DC Comics series Fables
(Started up in 2003), very directly and explicitly takes characters
and situations from past stories and adventures and the TV series
Once Upon A Time
appears to have derived directly from Fables.
So the only question for me is, does
the latest appropriation of the past do a good job of re-telling the
old story? I think Jack does indeed do the job quite well.
1 comment:
I like this very much.
"Jack the Giant Slayer." I would
like you to post stuff on my facebook page: Katherine Jankay.
Friends of Richmond Gardner.
email: thewizzj@hotmail.com
Pls. email me with comments from this Prawn Blog. tnx.
Katherine Jankay
Post a Comment